Jump to content
Big Change Coming to DonsTalk This July ×
DonsTalk

Leaderboard

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 26/02/24 in all areas

  1. Kilmarnock aren't punching above their weight though. Neither are St Mirren. Unless either of them end the season with the Scottish Cup, they are where they should be when you consider the state of the Scottish Premiership. Yes, Kilmarnock are having a good season, taking advantage of bigger clubs like Aberdeen and Hibs having a poor season and Dundee United being out of it. It's allowed Killie, St Mirren and Dundee to be higher than they normally would be. The Killie board - seeing European football within their grasp - have backed McInnes and they were able to offer more money than Motherwell to secure Van Veen, while they have picked up a fair few others on decent money. But I don't see any legacy building at Kilmarnock. Once the European campaign ends in August, Armstrong and Watson leave, Van Veen goes back to Holland, and (you hope) Aberdeen sort themselves out, Killie will head back down the table. And if McInnes came back here, he'd cause the same problems he did before. Yes, he might get more from this squad than Robson/Warnock, but it's short term success. Long term we'd continue to rely on loans and throw money at signings, and we'd probably slip back like we did in his first spell. We should be looking for better than McInnes. Goodwin actually achieved very little with St Mirren. He's not in the same conversation as the exciting prospects out there. He was - we thought - the right man when he came in as we needed a bit of pragmatism after Glassball had loads of possession but could not score or defend. Instead he tried to be something he wasn't and failed spectacularly. This time we need a manager that has a history of turning clubs into a team to be feared, who short term can galvanise the support and long term can make us a force again. We need a more attainable version of Philippe Clement to be honest. Scandinavia is a hotbed for cracking managers under 50 who are doing great things at small clubs on limited resources.
    4 points
  2. This only furthers my belief that gyms are for weirdos.
    1 point
  3. Clement has now joined the same gym as me, so we're basically pals now. As is Nick Walsh who is also a member. Together the three of us basically run Scottish football.
    1 point
  4. He isn't past it though. No one is past it at 32. And he's had good performances this season. But we're asking too much from him every week. He has a place in a properly thought out midfield.
    1 point
  5. After a few weeks, this sits with the manager. He needs to bring the aggression into training. He needs to put physical presence on the pitch. We all know that shinnie, Barron and clarkson is lightweight AF. Shinnie has a dirty streak but he's also past it and physically lacking in the tackle. I'd drop him tomorrow and make others take responsibility. I don't care if he plays ruby at CDM, we're far too soft. Many of these guys have come with good CV's which makes you think that the Cormack park culture is too easy. We're second to everything and rarely dominate play. That comes from an uncompetitive atmosphere. Just to clarify, I used to call it dels holiday camp. This isn't a new issue. Probably the last five years.
    1 point
  6. Aye, heard his fucking atrocious interview. "Not really his kind of team"? That's Derek Adams shite that is. Didn't do his research, he should leave now before he fucks off the whole team and drags us (further) into a relegation battle. If he can't get a team to play actual football, rather than kick people then he's not suitable.
    1 point
This leaderboard is set to London/GMT+01:00
×
×
  • Create New...